The One Thing Those Old Shetland Knitters Knew That Most of Us Never Did
Does the base of your thumb ache after a while?
Does it click, catch, or get stuck mid row?
Fine for twenty minutes. Then a deep ache that makes you put the whole lot down.
If you're a knitter or a crocheter, it isn't a question of if. It's when.
And you already know you won't stop. If you're sitting, you're stitching.
For four hundred years, the women who knitted for a living worked something out that most doctors still haven't.
They wore a sheath at the waist, anchored the needle in it, and let the tool take the weight. Less gripping. Less clenching.
The ones who still knit that way will tell you their hands are fine. Take the load off the working hand, and the joint underneath benefits.
Most of us were simply never handed that. It was passed down in Shetland and the Dales, by particular grandmothers. If it didn't reach you, you've gripped for decades with nothing taking the strain. That was never your fault.
So here's the question I hear from nearly every woman who sits in my chair.
Is there finally something that takes the load off the hand, the way those old knitters did, so you can keep going?
There is. Made for the way we knit today.
But first, what their instinct was reaching for, and why nothing since has quite matched it.
1. The old instinct was right: the working hand needs the load taken off it
Those women never immobilised the hand — that would have ended the work. They supported it, so the work could carry on for hours.
That's the distinction every modern gadget keeps missing. Compression gloves. A rigid thumb splint a doctor swore by. CBD rub. A "brace" off Amazon that broke at the seam in a week. I hear the same line from my patients over and over — they'd bought so many different types, all not designed for knitters. Each one built by someone who'd never picked up a needle, so each did one of two things: squeezed the whole hand and left the sore joint moving, or locked the thumb so stiff you couldn't work a stitch.
The sheath knew better four centuries ago. Support, not lock. That's the principle we'd lost — and the one worth getting back.
2. The Real Problem Is the Joint at the Base of Your Thumb
Those women never strapped the hand still. That would have ended the work. They supported it, so they could carry on for hours.
That is the thing every modern gadget keeps getting wrong.
The compression gloves. The rigid splint a doctor swore by. The CBD rub. The brace off Amazon that came apart at the seam in a week.
I hear the same line from knitters over and over. They'd bought so many different types, and not one was designed for knitters.
Each was built by someone who had never picked up a needle. So each did one of two things. It squeezed the whole hand and left the sore joint moving. Or it locked the thumb so stiff you couldn't work a single stitch.
The sheath had it right four hundred years ago. Support, not lock.
That is the principle we lost. And the one worth getting back.
3. The Swelling Is What Keeps Bringing the Pain Back
Once the joint starts shifting, your body swells the tissue around it to protect it. But that swelling is what stiffens the joint. So the next stitch hurts more. More pain, more swelling.
That's why resting doesn't break it. Put the needles down for a week, even two, and the pain settles. Pick them back up, and within an hour it's back. Usually worse than before.
4. Why the modern world still hasn't handed you what they had
This is the part I will be honest about, even if a few of my colleagues won't thank me for it.
A cortisone shot buys a few months. Then less. Then the talk turns to surgery.
"Change the way you hold the needles" asks you to relearn a craft you have done for fifty or sixty years.
And "just stop knitting" takes away the one thing that, for so many of the women I sit with, keeps both the hands and the mind working.
I have spent enough time with knitters and crocheters to know it was never just making things. So when a doctor hands all that over in six minutes, without once asking to see how you hold your needles, I understand why you walk out feeling dismissed.
None of it does the one simple thing those Shetland women had sorted four hundred years ago. Support the joint while you work.
The understanding was there all along. The modern world just never put it back in your hands.
Until now.
So What Can You Actually Do About It?
So what can you actually do about it?
There is really only one approach that helps for the long run, and the old crafters had it by instinct.
Support the joint at the base of the thumb while you work, instead of only calming the swelling afterwards.
That is harder than it sounds. To do it properly, the support has to manage three things at once.
✓ Support the one joint every glove and splint leaves moving
✓ Do it without locking the thumb, so you can still work a stitch
✓ Stay comfortable for the whole time you knit, not twenty minutes at a stretch
So one was made to do exactly that.
The modern form of a four-hundred-year-old idea
It is the first support built around the way a knitter's and crocheter's thumb actually moves.
The very thing the sheath was reaching for, made with materials those old knitters could only have dreamed of.
✓ A contoured pad supports the joint at the base of your thumb, the exact one other braces leave moving
✓ Smooth fabric that glides, so it won't snag your wool or catch your needles
✓ All four fingers stay free, so you grip and tension the yarn just as you always have
✓ Soft and light enough to settle in and knit for hours, not twenty minutes at a stretch
Those Shetland women had the right instinct, with a sheath at the waist and a lifetime of feel. This is that same instinct, the load taken off the joint, finally in a form made for your hands, on your sofa, today.
The understanding was always yours. You were just never handed the modern shape of it.
It comes with a full 60-day money-back guarantee.
Wear it, knit in it, and if it doesn't hold that thumb the way it has for the women I treat, send it back and they'll refund every penny.
— Dr. Simmons
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
- Opens in a new window.