Health
June 25, 2026
4 Reasons Your Thumb Pain Keeps Coming Back When You Knit and Crochet
Margaret Whitmore
Last Updated June 25th, 2026
109,483 Views
2 min Reading Time*
Read on to find the likely culprits behind your thumb pain, and what helped me continue knitting.
1. The Splints, Gloves, and Creams You've Already Tried Were Never Designed For Knitters
It isn't that nothing works. It's that nothing you tried was made for knitters.
Compression gloves. A rigid thumb splint your doctor swore by. CBD rub. Maybe a "brace" off Amazon that broke at the seam in a week, or cortisone shots that bought you six weeks the first time.
I'd bought so many different types of braces over the years, all not designed for knitters. Every one built by someone who's never picked up a needle. None of them let me knit in them.
2. The Real Problem Is the Joint at the Base of Your Thumb
It's one joint: the CMC, at the base of your thumb, sitting on a small bone called the trapezium. Years of gripping the needle have worn it loose. Now every stitch shifts it past itself. One shift you'd never feel. But it's a thousand an hour. And as long as it keeps sliding, the pain has nowhere to settle.
That's why it flares twenty minutes in and eases the moment you set the needles down. Age doesn't come and go with the stitching. A loose joint does.
3. The Swelling Is What Keeps Bringing the Pain Back
Once the joint starts shifting, your body swells the tissue around it to protect it. But that swelling is what stiffens the joint. So the next stitch hurts more. More pain, more swelling.
That's why resting doesn't break it. Put the needles down for a week, even two, and the pain settles. Pick them back up, and within an hour it's back. Usually worse than before.
4. Every 'Solution' Doctors Offer You Makes Knitting Harder, Not Easier
This is the part that makes most of us furious.
A cortisone shot buys a few months, then less, then the talk turns to surgery.
"Try Continental" asks you to relearn how you hold the yarn after 50, 60, sometimes 70 years.
"Just stop knitting" takes away the one thing that keeps your hands and your head working. This isn't a hobby. It's our lifeline. I'd be lost without it.
So What Can You Actually Do About It?
There's only one way to get lasting relief: support the joint that's actually sliding, the CMC at the base of your thumb, not just the swelling it causes.
That's harder than it sounds. The brace has to:
✓ Support the one joint every glove and splint leaves moving
✓ Do it without locking the thumb, so you can still work a stitch
✓ Be comfortable enough to keep on the whole time you knit, not for twenty minutes at a stretch
So a hand therapist who works with knitters and crocheters set out to build one.
The First Brace Made for the Way a Knitter's Thumb Moves
It's the first brace made around how a knitter's thumb actually moves:
A contoured pad supports the CMC joint at the base of your thumb, the exact one other braces miss
All four fingers stay free, so you grip and tension the yarn as you always have
Soft, lightweight and comfortable, so you can settle in and knit for hours
I left the link above if you want to look.
If your hands are anything like mine were, it's worth a look.
— Margaret
Most relevant
17 comments
Olivia Wilson
Can anybody vouch for these?
3
Like
Reply
1d
Emily Lewis
Yes, these braces are the only thing that helps. They're not a miracle, but definitely provide extra support. Before the pain at the base of my thumb had got so bad that I had to stop after twenty minutes. With these braces, I'm back to knitting most evenings again.
Like
Reply
1d
Annie Jones
Crocheting is my life line. Yes, arthritic pain. I am not stupid enough to go near a doctor. Knitting for 61 years and crocheting for 33 years.
3
Like
Reply
3d
Zoe Cummings
Mine just arrived today, thank you! I'm knitting again. I had to stop for a while but the suppopry works beautifully which is why I have ordered more. (I don't want to wear one out and have to shelve my needles again) Thank you for developing this.
Like
Reply
3d
Dawn Taylor
Thanks for putting this on, I am having problems with recovering from a trigger finger op , after previous successful ops on other fingers in the past. You inspired me to be proactive and have an appointment with a hand remedial clinic so hopefully this will ease my problem.
3
Like
Reply
1w
Sheila Simmons
I stopped knitting due to arthritis in my index fingers. I’ve now started felting, it’s just as satisfying.
1
Like
Reply
1w
Shirley Baker
I am 71 and in the last 2 years had both thumb joints replaced and was told by my physio that the best exercise was knitting which has helped me get the movement back in my hands.
8
Like
Reply
2w
Margaret Summers
Has anyone actually tried this? My thumbs have been getting worse for years and my doctor just keeps offering me cortisone shots. I'm 64 and frankly terrified of surgery.
3
Like
Reply
2w
Susan White
Margaret I bought one in February. Wear this every time I sit down to knit and the deep ache has definitely reduced.
1
Like
Reply
2w
Kathie Jackson
Switching from English style throwing to European style scooping helped me over a period of thumb problems, as did adopting shorter (the bit you hold) circular needles help my wrists.
2
Like
Reply
1w
Pauline Smith
Ok but is it actually different from the $30 ones on Amazon?? I've bought about five of those over the years and every single one broke at the seam within a week. Usually at night
4
Like
Reply
3w
Janet Bailey
Janet I had the exact same thought. The Amazon ones either fall apart or they're so bulky you can't actually knit while wearing them. This one is slim enough that you can still hold the needles properly. Two months in and the structure hasn't budged.
6
Like
Reply
2w
Thelma Davies
Embroiders, Crocheters, have the same, problem with Arthritis. Painful, but, what else is there, when you love it so much, plus if you’re in a group , it’s extra special. We have to keep our fingers and, brain active. I have been hand sewing for over seventy years, and, don’t intend to stop now. Just adapt.
7
Like
Reply
3w
Jennifer Bale
It doesn't say whether it's for the left or right hand. I need it for my right hand.
Like
Reply
3w
Julie McGrann
Jennifer, it says each order contains a pair, I wanted it for my left and found the info in the product details section.
Like
Reply
3w
Avery Jackson
Does anyone know how long the shipping takes? Want to buy some for the girls at knit n natter
1
Like
Reply
4w
Linda Wright
Hey Avery, mine arrived after about a week
Like
Reply
4w
Fagan Helen
Hi this is the second review im writing so I am sorry for flooding your page Hand Hearth Knitting .
I have been using my hand stabilisers for the past week and wanted to share my experience of using them.
They are a game changer, I wear prescribed stabilisers daily and in comparison these are the most comfortable by far. I had literally given up thinking that I wouldnt be able to knit again. I was often in tears thinking I would not be able to complete any of my projects.
These stabilisers are a life saver for me. In comparison with other products I have tried. They are soft yet offer great support to my thumbs making knitting easier and enjoyable again. The fabric is so soft and comfortable to wear. I love the range of colours and they are styled in such a fashionable way that I would wear them outside as they offer good support unlike others which are cumbersome offering great support. Sizing is accurate and I plan on buying more in the future.
Thank you Hand Hearth Knitting
Like
Reply
4w
7
Jane Gibson
The hand stabilizers arrived safely today, and thank you for the circular needle. The gloves are perfect. Thanks so much. I will be a return customer for sure!
3
Like
Reply
4w
Susan Smith
I received mine yesterday, purple size small.I tried them last night and they are great.I wish I had bought them sooner.I can highly recommend Thank you Hand Hearth
5
Like
Reply
4w
Christie Cares
I received mine last week. They are like a hug for your hands. Dealing with this company's kind customer service has been a refreshing experience. I recommend 100%!
2
Like
Reply
4w
Christie Cares
I received mine last week. They are like a hug for your hands. Dealing with this company's kind customer service has been a refreshing experience. I recommend 100%!
4
Like
Reply
4w
Anne Hewitt
I have had to use gloves for arthritis for years. But the silicon dots for grip catch on the wool.
I am impressed with these. They made a massive difference to my thumb joint. I was so surprised! Thank you!
3
Like
Reply
4w
Lester Wilson
I like this product and it's well worth purchasing. That said, consult an orthopedic doctor if you have bad pain. A simple steroid shot in the problem tendon fixed my pain issue.
It's worth a try.
I still use this product though and recommend it.
5
Like
Reply
4w
Debbie Higgs
This product is a blessing to me. Eliminating that little twinge of discomfort is like eliminating a distraction. I will end up with one in every knitting bag.
2
Like
Reply
4w
Joyce Schnarr
They are worth it! You may need the working hand in the future. I mainly need the holding hand, but they both feel great when knitting. I just ordered more, as I like them so much.
3
Like
Reply
4w
Janet Legere
I just tried my new ones with my heavy yarn project. They were great for my fine gauge knitting and I'm so happy I don't have to give up my heavy yarn project. I knitted for almost 45 minutes with NO pain, I'm so stoked!!!
7
Like
Reply
4w